All posts by alleongvbc

Uber’s Attempt To Disrupt Vancouver Stalls


Uber’s global expansion met with resistance from taxicab companies in various cities around the world, including Vancouver, Canada. Uber’s technology is innovative but technically not disruptive, as it does not change the way taxi services are provided, but it does create more efficiency. By contrast, digital photography completely disrupted and destroyed the film and photofinishing industry. And ride sharing between cities has been around for at least two decades. Uber’s disruption to the taxi industry may come because it bypasses transportation and taxi bylaws, regulations, and barriers to entry (such as training, fleet costs and insurance, plus the cost of medallions).


Uber’s company story began in December 2008 when Travis Kalanick and Garrett Camp went to Paris, France, to attend a LeWeb technology conference. When they decided to take a cab, they both realized how difficult it was to get one. Shortly after they returned home, they developed an app for the iPhone that would help people get around. In January 2010, Uber’s first prototype test ran in New York City and then San Francisco.

Although the company operates in the transportation industry, the folks at Uber would say that Uber is not a transportation provider, nor does it employ cars and drivers. Uber operates a system, or platform, that connects passengers to drivers via smartphone. A mobile app sends an email to a car, based on the passenger’s location. Transactions are automatically billed to the rider, who has a credit card on file with Uber, allowing for cashless transactions. The company’s business model is simple. Uber recruits drivers and pays their commercial taxi licence. It then connects those drivers with local rental companies. Drivers receive passenger requests via the Uber real-time app.

For Uber, the strategic and capital asset management advantages of this model are significant. The crowdsourced Uber driver bears the burden of car ownership, maintenance and costs. Moreover, Uber owns no fleet, which expands and contracts based on supply and demand. Uber is the world’s largest taxi company, but it owns no vehicles.

The company has received billions in funding from numerous investors and venture capitalists. Despite this tremendous success in raising money and its fast expansion plan, Uber has strong competitors in various geographical markets worldwide: Lyft and Curb in the USA, Grab in Southeast Asia (Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand, Vietnam, Indonesia and the Philippines), Ola in India, and Didi Chuxing in China.


The Uber system is efficient and cost-effective. Rides are requested by customers on the app and drivers are crowdsourced using their own personal vehicle. Fares are set by the company, prepaid by customers with a credit card or PayPal, and are typically 20% to 50% less expensive than those of a taxicab ride. Cars are clean, if not cleaner, than taxicabs. Riders can select from several types of transportation options available: cars, minivans and luxury cars (“UberSELECT”). In communities with populations over 30,000, getting an Uber takes as little as three to five minutes, depending on the time of day. Fares are pre-set and prepaid, and routes are mapped with GPS. Passengers no longer have unscrupulous taxicab drivers who take the long route or drive in circles to increase the fare. Assaults on Uber drivers are uncommon, since customers must register their identity and have a valid credit card or PayPal account to get a ride (there’s an audit trail).

However, as of December 1, 2016, as reported by, there have been 46 alleged assaults by drivers, 206 alleged sexual assaults and harassments, 9 alleged kidnappings and 10 deaths.

The BBC reported that an Indian Uber driver was charged and subsequently convicted of rape in 2015, and Bloomberg reported a study from Christopher Knittel, a professor at the MIT Sloan School of Management, which found racial discrimination by Uber and Lyft drivers against black passengers (pickup failure).The study found that Uber drivers disproportionately cancelled on riders with “black-sounding” names, even though the company penalizes drivers who cancel frequently.


But what has happened in Vancouver? And, in fact, in the entire province of British Columbia?

Vancouver city councillor Geoff Meggs describes the unique situation that Uber faces in B.C. and in the Greater Vancouver Regional District (GVRD). A primary reason for Uber’s lack of adoption is legal and related to insurance for prospective Uber drivers; he stated that Uber drivers can’t get insured throughout B.C. because the Insurance Corporation of British Columbia (ICBC), a Crown corporation, has a legal monopoly on auto insurance in the province. However, drivers can get an insurance policy on the ICBC website—it just appears to be expensive, and it’s rated at the same class as limousine and cab drivers.

Meggs stated, “Unlike Montreal, Ottawa, Toronto or Edmonton, the City of Vancouver has an overlapping jurisdiction with its provincial counterpart. This means that both the city and the province have their rules and requirements, mostly complementary but not always, in the transportation sector. For example, the provincial regulators set the number of taxis in each jurisdiction and issue passenger transportation licences, while the city adds rules such as a criminal background check and a chauffeur permit from the Vancouver Police, as well as a low-emission vehicle requirement (which favours such vehicles as the Toyota Prius). The additional uniqueness of Vancouver, besides the fact that the city is not an amalgamated municipality, is that its auto insurance is regulated and controlled by the provincial government, i.e., ICBC.”

Furthermore, there are safety and service quality concerns regarding Uber drivers.

Taxicab companies argue that established protocols for criminal background checks and taxicab driver screening, as well as licensing, eliminate these issues of public safety and discrimination. The added cost of licensing (arguably quality control) is included in the taxi licensing fee, which runs upward of $1 million, and that’s why a taxicab ride costs almost twice as much as one from Uber or Lyft. Councillor Meggs stated, “The City of Vancouver’s position was that we wanted to move to ride sharing in a way that protected the assets that we feel we have as a result of the taxi system. So we think there’s some real benefits to it.” He characterized Uber as “very pleasant people, but the overlying message was rude”.

The additional regulations from the City of Vancouver in the tourism sector, as well as in the transportation industry, stem from the fact that “the stakeholders are extra-fussy,” says Meggs. “If there is an opportunity for the taxi industry to innovate and meet this competition, we would welcome that.”


During an interview with Michael van Hemmen, public policy manager at Uber, we asked specific questions about the company’s market entry into Vancouver and their approach to marketing in this unique environment. We asked about their approach to managing not only ICBC and the insurance policy issue, but also about lobbying governments to change rules about insurance.

Van Hemmen stated, “So the insurance regime is different in B.C. than that in other provinces. From a policy perspective, the mode that we see best is coalitions. It’s one thing for a single company to say, “We want you to change these rules,” but what we’re also doing is we’re going around to a variety of stakeholders, including the Vancouver Board of Trade, the Suzuki Foundation and other types of organizations, such as tourism and the cruise ship industry, and highlighting the benefits that this improved urban mobility provides not just for Uber, but for their organizations, their stakeholders and society more broadly. As government hears from a wide variety of stakeholders that this actually should be done and it should be done sooner rather than later, that’s when government starts to pay more attention and it starts to act.”

And when probed about whether he thought marketing efforts in Vancouver were different from those of other jurisdictions that do not have these policy issues, van Hemmen elaborated on the subject. “These challenges arise everywhere. So there’s truth in that. We’re continuing to iterate and evolve products. There’s politics associated. In many ways, it’s the same. When you’re looking to change or update rules, the way that you encourage that chance to happen is to engage potential customers or partners, and in that sense, it is marketing.”

“You have to remember, we’re a very young company,” said van Hemmen, who seemed to suggest that policies, plans and strategies were not fully in place and Uber was learning as it acted, or reacted, to governments and markets.


Some existing Uber drivers might argue that the quality of work and revenues are no better than those associated with driving a regular taxi, but besides creating jobs, Uber might consider the following:

• Sharing its data from its big data analytic tools with local city government to improve transportation planning

• Reinvesting some of its profits in local charities and giving back where it operates (TELUS’s Day of Giving motto We Give Where We Live is a great example!)

• Engaging in a friendly and open way with all levels of government, not just provincial, and demonstrating collaboration with stakeholders, including taxi companies

• Proposing a partnership or alliance strategy with taxi companies to avoid competition, which would result in lower wages, as the success of Uber lies in the promise of always having passengers

• Incorporating a feature on the app to provide riders with the option of choosing a standard taxicab

Taxicab companies might consider the following:

• Improving customer service and metrics for service quality

• Increasing vehicle comfort and learning about best practices in the retail, banking and travel sectors, for example; customers are always willing to pay more for a premium experience, better services and safety

• Eliminating the need for a dispatcher and developing their own platform

• Implementing a marketing program to develop repeat customers and thus customer lifetime value, rather than one-off transactions

• Using digital technologies and learning about the wants and needs of millennials and iGen (or Cloud Gen), namely, access, experience and sharing, which appear to replace the concept of ownership

• Reviewing the entire cost structure and eliminating steps or activities that bring no value to riders

In addition to these general business recommendations, we have identified three specific marketing ideas that may or may not have been considered by Uber, but which we believe would facilitate Uber’s market entry into Vancouver.


1. View marketing for Uber to include public lobbying and demand generation, combined to showcase voter enthusiasm to change legislation and policies that prohibit Uber’s operation in B.C.

  • a. Develop an integrated media campaign (TV, radio, print, social media, etc.) to both register support for Uber and lobby government officials; the cost of this campaign should be equivalent to, or less than, the lost opportunity cost of revenues derived from Uber services in a city or jurisdiction equal to the size of the GVRD or B.C.
  • b. Dedicate a legislative or lobbying campaign to businesses wanting to partner with or who would benefit from Uber’s market entry (travel & tourism)

2. Create a pre-marketing campaign aimed at Uber users and drivers that funnels them to the mobile app and website to solicit further action.

  • a. Lobby government and ICBC, as well as their partners and associations
  • b. Get the public to sign a petition (by riders) to lobby government to change rules

3. Launch educational campaigns (surrounding issues, legislation, service, benefits, myths and laws).

  • a. For Uber drivers, dispel the myth that ICBC is not providing insurance. In fact, drivers can already get ICBC coverage if they have a Class 4 licence. They can be insured to drive for Uber in Vancouver.
  • b. Increase the number of Uber drivers by creating a taxi driver “switch” campaign to encourage taxi drivers to drive for Uber; facilitate market entry by increasing the supply of qualified drivers
  • c. Start Uber app services in the GVRD and throughout B.C.

In conclusion, Uber attempted to enter the Vancouver market without understanding the impact of government-controlled (monopolistic) insurance and other legal issues not found in other jurisdictions. While it has attempted to lobby the local city and provincial governments on changing rules and bylaws regarding car-sharing services, it has failed to develop a comprehensive and focused strategy to enter this highly regulated market.

The authors have provided eight strategic and tactical marketing recommendations for Uber to accelerate market entry in the GVRD

Top 10 Marketing Tips You Need For 2017

Marketing TipsStrategic marketing is evolving because of technology, innovation and globalization. In 2017, successful marketers will use what they know, integrate their industry expertise and adapt to these new changes.

1. Market research and analysis is critical to understanding your customers, value propositions, positioning and for gaining insights in B2B and B2C markets. Start with research to arm yourself with the ability to make strategic decisions on markets, products, pricing, user-experience design and creative approaches to branding. Because of web technology and globalization, foreign markets have now become accessible for even the smallest firms. Entering foreign markets requires you to understand a country’s language, customs, demographics, industry competitors, and unique opportunities, challenges and risks.

Pinar Yildirim, Assistant Professor of Marketing at The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania said, “…the future of marketing research will be hugely driven by Big Data and analytics, and this is an exciting direction. Two things are new. First, there are many new and unusual data sources (social networks, mobile data, path data, eye tracking, etc.). Second, we now have a greater ability to connect these high numbers of data sources.”

2. Web or online strategy is critical because most customers will research, investigate, consider and even buy from your firm online. Understand the benefits of the major content management systems (CMS) like WordPress, Joomla, Magento or Drupal. Or if you decide to build your own site from scratch, how will you plan the extensibility of your website for the next 3, 5 or 10 years? Ensure that your SEO efforts, Google AdWords and Analytics code, shopping cart, landing pages, links are accurately and well-integrated. Last strategic SEO, rather than tactical SEO will be what works. That said, you can use programs like to keep track of, recognise and disavow low quality links so you don’t get penalized. According to Rand Fishkin, at Moz, Google’s new algorithms will catch up to real-world public relations, branding and marketing efforts, and penalize approaches that historically try to trick the system: so, focus on building a strong brand. And, blog: a HubSpot report indicated that B2B companies that blog generated 67% more leads than those that do not blog.

3. Social marketing evolves to be more powerful in driving customers through the sales funnel — from creating awareness, and virally engaging with customers and non-customers of your product alike. Everyone has or forms an opinion about your product or service with a few conversations. Use applications like Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook, Hootsuite, Sysomos to engage, analyze and measure social media performance and return on investment (ROI). All major social media platforms have great advertising platforms with analytics built in. New programs like AdEspresso provide automated design and massive multivariate testing of Facebook ads. Once prospects or customers are engaged, switch from social to email for better conversion rates (sales or actions) like driving your prospects to visit or call. Use #hashtags and strong calls to action. Going viral globally is both an opportunity and a risk. Plan accordingly.

4. Marketing automation and email marketing have revolutionized both the B2B and B2C sales funnel. With fine-detail analysis and programming with applications like Eloqua, Marketo and Pardot, you can intelligently drive prospects towards being loyal customers with advanced email drip and lead nurture campaigns, lead scoring, rules-based alerts and analytics. New applications like Hotjar, Unbounce and provide conversion tools to optimize your online user experience. Use (like SpamAssassin) to verify your email campaigns won’t get you into trouble. Social media is great for gaining awareness and engagement but a poor vehicle for conversions to sales. Email should be used to drive conversions. According to Yesmail, more than 25% of email driven purchases were completed via mobile devices in the 2nd quarter of 2015.

5. Branding and UX Design is both creative and strategic. Ensure that your branding effort is in line with your market research in terms of message, demographics and positioning. You want total alignment of your visual and logical messages, arguments and brand metaphors. Ensure your brand colors, logo and theme all harmonize, resonate and don’t conflict with your product or firm’s positioning (and product price points). Achieve a consistency with your brand identity, packaging, website, sales collateral, invoices and forms, signage, advertising, videos and internal and external communications. Create a powerful brand personality with a strong communications platform and voice. David Aaker, Vice Chairman of Prophet, developed three personality models to help guide marketers in developing powerful brands: the self-expression model, the relationship basis model, and the functional benefit representation model.

6.Public Relations and Experiential Events are effective for B2B and B2C sales, external and channel development (partners, suppliers, alliances, resellers, OEMs), targeted or mass communications to the public or specific customers, investors and the community. Use experiential events to engage with your audience and tell compelling, rich stories that resonate and are memorable. Pitch media on newsworthy and interesting story angles, and plan an annual calendar of content, and press releases that thematically tell a complete story (who, what, when, where, why) about your firm, products and services. Have a media-trained spokesperson for your organization, armed with a printed or electronic press kit (EPK) with a company fact sheet, FAQs, executive bios and photos ready for publishing. Oftentimes, events are coupled with media relations activities because live announcements have an excitement and showmanship built-in (for broadcast) at a convention, conference or hotel with press and media relations present. Wow your audiences (analysts, press, customers) here to reach and amplify your bullhorn locally, nationally and globally.

7. Sales, channel marketing, and loyalty (evangelism) is the top priority for marketers in B2C organizations. Because of the lack of data (industrial or business buyers, compared with consumers) marketers are unable to rely with statistical confidence on research data to make decisions. Business customer surveys, messaging, pain points and reliance on sales to gather that information can pose risks (accuracy, validity, interpretation). Marketing must consider the full buying team (finance, president, operations, and other decision makers and influencers) in a group buying decision and ensure that the website, collateral and other touchpoints addresses all buyer requirements and points of resistance encountered by your VP Sales. Ensure that you have a strong sales leader, the team is properly incentivized, rewarded and recognized (in internal communications and corporate events) for their performance. Using CRM technology (like, Pardot, Microsoft Dynamics, SugarCRM, and Marketo) helps with sales and channel management. Deploy ingredient branding and co-op advertising programs to incentivize channel partners. Enhance loyalty through service dedication, going beyond the call of duty, implementing NetPromoter 2.0 (How likely would you recommend question) and implementing a loyalty program — Hubspot identifies a few: VIP benefits, Rewards, Points, Tier system, Values-based non-monetary program, and a Partners program. And if you don’t want to run your own loyalty program, pay for inclusion into AirMiles. Apple customers and partners became evangelists of the company. This culture was promoted from within Apple (Evangelists) and its loyalist underdog culture helped save it from near oblivion in the late 90s to its current $634 billion valuation today.

8. Advertising and promotions: print and online (PPC) advertising, direct response, video, events, media planning, TV, radio and outdoor require either an in-house or external creative talent (designer, copywriter, developer) to execute well. Certainly test all creative before implementing to validate response rates to ensure creative is on brand, on message, memorable and resonates with your audience. Always develop KPIs and metrics in creative and ad performance to justify media spending and to spot sales trends.

The newest thing to come down the pipe is programmatic advertising. It’s new and will change how advertising (online, TV) is brokered, managed and sold and purchased. Essentially, its software that will allow real-time bidding for ad inventory based on big data insights (demographics, intention, behaviour) that reduces insertion orders and change orders, is platform-agnostic and optimizes ad spending. It helps sell ad inventory for publishers and ad networks. But, it’s more. Programmatic advertising uses data and technology can improve the advertising effectiveness. The lion’s share of inventory is remnant or network inventory, but this is changing to premium ad space too. A good primer on understanding this technology is found here (Adweek).

9. Product design, product marketing is critical in your marketing toolkit. One of the “four Ps” designing your product or service well, innovating and packaging or bundling your product will hopefully provide a strategic competitive advantage. Unless you are marketing wheat or iron ore, your product or service is likely differentiable. Identify the most salient value proposition and business or customer “drivers” –why a customer wants to buy your product and validate with research. Gain feedback and improve the product iteratively through innovation and a continuous improvement process. Ideation and brainstorm sessions, killing “sacred cows,” may help you innovate. The Internet has destroyed postal services. Mobile phones have destroyed the photofinishing and photographic film markets altogether. If you don’t do it, someone else will.

10. Pricing — work with your CFO or VP Finance to determine the right prices for your products and services. This is a complex and iterative process where some firms will deploy technology to make minute-by-minute changes based on inventory and demand. The reason is that pricing affects your strategic positioning and brand image. Understand price elasticity, a consumer or buyer’s willingness to pay (WTP), market skimming, cost-plus, marginal cost, market penetration, psychological and other approaches to pricing depending on your situation. Understand channel effects on pricing strategy (online, retail, reseller, direct), mark-ups per channel and avoid channel price conflicts. A new revenue model called “Freemium” has become popular especially with technology and software (SaaS) firms.